Weekly Caselaw Updates

Sign up here to receive a weekly email with summaries of every precedential case out of the Third Circuit and the appellate courts in Pennsylvania and New Jersey. No fluff. No filler. No fee.

United States v. Hart

3rd Circuit

December 21, 2020

The Third Circuit ran into a novel issue surrounding the First Step Act in United States v. Hart. The Act was passed in 2018, and it made retroactive certain reductions in mandatory-minimum sentences that were passed into law in 2012. Under the Act, eligible prisoners could petition to reduce their sentences per the 2012 reductions. After the Act was passed, a committee of individuals from the Federal Defender’s Office and the U.S. Attorney’s Office negotiated a large number of new sentences for eligible prisoners. Mr. Hart was one such prisoner, and he accepted the sentence the committee negotiated for him. But as the caselaw developed — most notably United States v. Easter, 975 F.3d 318 (3d Cir. 2020) —  Mr. Hart realized that he might have left a few years on the table. So he petitioned a second time for a reduction under the Act. The 3rd Circuit held that the Act prohibits a second bite at the apple. But the 3rd Circuit found that provision to be non-jurisdictional. And since the government consented to a new sentencing hearing, the 3rd Circuit remanded the case for Mr. Hart to be sentenced a third time.

Scroll down to read the court's full opinion

Heavy Workload

Heavy Workload



 Other<br />Personal<br />Commitments


Hiring Attorney Contact Us
Sullivan Simon
Attorneys with 20+ years of litigation experience.

requests basic information
about case
Within 24 hours,

flat-fee quote

Delivers Final
  • On Time
  • On Budget
  • Ready to File